Stamp card or punch card?
They're the same loyalty card marked a different way. A punch card gets a hole from a hole punch; a stamp card gets ink from a rubber stamp, a sticker or a signature. This maker leaves each box blank, with a small number, so the ink lands on clean paper.
| Stamp card | Punch card | |
|---|---|---|
| How a visit is marked | A rubber stamp, a sticker or initials | A hole punch |
| What staff keep at the till | A self-inking stamp | A shaped hole punch |
| Boxes | Blank and numbered, round or square | Circles with a faint mark to punch through |
| Best for | Cafés, bakeries and shops with a counter | Busy counters where a punch is quicker than ink |
| Copying | A stamp with your logo is hard to fake | A matching punch is easy to buy |
Prefer a hole punch? The punch card maker draws the same card with circles to punch through, and lists punch card ideas for 12 kinds of business.
Choosing a stamp for your cards
- Size: On a ten-box card each box is about 3/8 inch (10 mm) across, and about 1/2 inch (12 mm) with five boxes. A round self-inking stamp that size, or a little smaller, leaves a clean mark.
- Your own logo: A custom stamp of your logo costs little from an office supply or stamp shop, and it is the best protection against customers filling their own cards with a stamp from the craft store.
- Ink: Self-inking stamps are quicker at a busy till than a stamp and pad. Use a quick-drying ink on matte card stock so the mark doesn't smear in a wallet.
- No stamp yet?: A staff member's initials or a sticker works on day one. Choose square boxes if you use stickers.
What to write on a stamp card
Keep the rule to one line people can read at the counter. The maker writes the reward line for you from the number of boxes and the reward; these are other ways to say it.
- Collect 10 stamps, get a free coffee.
- Buy 9 haircuts, your 10th is on us.
- One stamp for every $10 you spend. Fill the card for a free dessert.
- Fine print: One stamp per visit. No cash value. Not valid with other offers.
How many stamps for your business
Pick one of the ideas above the maker to load its colors and reward. As a rule, the more often people come, the more boxes the card can have.
| Business | Boxes | Reward |
|---|---|---|
| Coffee shop | 10 | a free drink of your choice |
| Pizzeria | 8 | a free large pizza |
| Restaurant | 6 | a free starter |
| Bakery | 10 | a free pastry |
| Bubble tea | 10 | a free drink |
| Ice cream shop | 8 | a free scoop |
| Barbershop | 6 | a free haircut |
| Nail salon | 8 | free nail art on your next set |
| Car wash | 5 | a free deluxe wash |
| Juice bar | 10 | a free smoothie |
| Pet groomer | 5 | a free bath and brush |
| Yoga or fitness studio | 10 | a free class |
When to move from paper to digital
A paper stamp card is the cheapest way to see whether regulars care. Once they do, a digital stamp card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet stops lost and copied cards and lets you message everyone who has one. Read about digital stamp cards or see the programs for coffee shops, restaurants and salons.