Square Loyalty and Loyalty Cards solve the same problem from opposite ends. Square Loyalty is one part of a point of sale system, and you set it up by hand. Loyalty Cards is a standalone program that sits beside whatever you already use, and AI sets it up for you.
The short answer: choose Loyalty Cards if you don’t use Square, you want AI to make your card and flyers, or you want a card in both wallets without changing how you take payments. If you run on Square and want points added at checkout, Square Loyalty may suit you.
AI makes your card in about a minute
Point Loyalty Cards at your Google listing, your website or your Instagram, or describe your business in a sentence. AI creates a branded card with its own artwork, colors and rewards, ready for Apple Wallet and Google Wallet. Then ask for changes in plain words, or edit anything yourself.
Square Loyalty is set up in the Square Dashboard, where you choose how customers earn and add each reward yourself.
Full-art poster passes on iOS 27
iOS 27 gave Apple Wallet a new look called Poster Generic, where your artwork fills the whole pass and the details sit on top. Apple made it optional, so a loyalty card only gets the new look if the company behind it builds it.
Loyalty Cards already has. On iOS 27 your card becomes a poster pass, with your stamps or rewards over your artwork, and AI can design that artwork along with the rest of your card. iPhones on older versions keep the classic card, so every customer sees the best their phone can show. It is included on every plan.
Square’s loyalty page does not mention poster passes.
Flyers that sell the program for you
Customers need a reason to scan, so Loyalty Cards turns your card into a flyer with the card, the rewards and the QR code already on it. Choose a poster, counter card, handout or business card, then print it or download a PDF for a print shop.
Tell AI the look you want and it redesigns the flyer, with new artwork if it needs it. Your card and QR code always stay on it, and both are included on every plan.
Square offers in-store signage to print, and its loyalty page does not mention AI design.
Side by side
We checked these details on each company’s own website on October 31, 2026, and the free plans and free days again on November 11, 2026. Square’s prices are for the US.
| Loyalty Cards | Square Loyalty | |
|---|---|---|
| Setting it up | AI designs the card and rewards in about a minute | You set the rules and rewards in the Square Dashboard |
| Card artwork | AI creates it | Not mentioned on its loyalty page |
| Reads your website or Instagram | Yes | Not mentioned on its loyalty page |
| Full-art poster pass on iOS 27 | Yes, on every plan | Not mentioned on its loyalty page |
| Flyers and posters | Made from your card, in four formats | In-store signage to print |
| Redesign a flyer with AI | Yes on Plus and Pro, describe the look you want | Not mentioned on its loyalty page |
| Starting price | $25 a month, billed yearly | Included in Square Plus, $49 a month per location |
| Billed monthly | $30 a month | $49 a month per location |
| What else that plan covers | Loyalty only | Point of sale, inventory, marketing and staff tools |
| Card processing | None, you keep your own provider | 2.5% + 15¢ in person on Square Plus |
| Point of sale needed | Any, or none | Square’s own products |
| Apple Wallet | Yes | Yes, as a pass |
| Google Wallet | Yes | Not mentioned on its loyalty page |
| Stamp cards | Yes | Not mentioned, but points can be earned per visit |
| Points | Yes | Yes |
| How customers earn | Staff scan a wallet card | At Square checkout, for example with a phone number |
| Free plan | Yes, up to 50 customers, no time limit | No; Square Free leaves out loyalty, and Square Loyalty is free for 30 days |
When Loyalty Cards is the better choice
- You don’t use Square. Moving your point of sale and card processing is a big change just to get a loyalty program.
- You don’t want to set it up by hand. AI makes the card, the artwork and the rewards, and then the flyer.
- You want the new look on iOS 27. Your artwork fills the whole pass, and iPhones on older versions keep the classic card.
- You have Android customers. The same program covers Google Wallet and Apple Wallet.
- You want a stamp card. Customers see their stamps on the pass, like a paper card.
- You want to start free. Free covers up to 50 customers with no time limit, while Square Loyalty is free for 30 days and then comes with Square Plus.
- You only want to pay for loyalty. Plus costs less than Square Plus, and it adds no processing fees because it doesn’t handle payments.
When Square Loyalty may fit
- You already use Square and want points to be automatic. Customers can earn at checkout without staff taking another step.
- You want more than loyalty. Square Plus also covers inventory, marketing and staff tools.
What about switching from Square?
You don’t have to switch your point of sale to use Loyalty Cards, and you can run it beside Square if you prefer a wallet card. You would give up automatic earning at checkout, though, since Loyalty Cards doesn’t connect to Square.
Sources: Square Loyalty, Square pricing, Square plans announcement, Create a loyalty program, Square Loyalty in Ireland for its signage, Apple’s poster pass guide, and our own pricing. Competitors change their plans, so check their site before you decide.
Last updated November 13, 2026









