We compared the loyalty programs an independent restaurant is most likely to consider, on the things that decide whether diners actually use them: what they cost, how a diner joins, how they earn, and what you need to run them.
About this list: we make Loyalty Cards, so it appears first, and we’ve tried to be fair about where the others are better. We checked every price and feature on the company’s own website, on October 31, 2026 for Loopy Loyalty, Stamp Me and Square, and on November 6, 2026 for the rest, and checked each one’s free plan and free days again on November 11, 2026. Prices are in US dollars and change often, so check before you buy.
The short list
| Best for | Starting price | How diners join | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loyalty Cards | A wallet card designed for you, at the lowest price | Free for up to 50 customers, then $25 a month billed yearly or $30 monthly | Scan a QR code, save to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet |
| Toast Loyalty | Restaurants already on Toast | Not published | At Toast checkout or online ordering |
| Square Loyalty | Restaurants already on Square | Included in Square Plus, $49 a month per location | At Square checkout |
| Loopy Loyalty | A plain wallet stamp card | $25 a month billed monthly | Scan a QR code, save to the wallet |
| Stamp Me | Stamping with a hardware tap device | $49 a month | Download the Stamp Me app |
| Boomerangme | Many card types and automated marketing | $164 a month billed yearly | Scan a QR code, save to the wallet |
| Kangaroo Rewards | Restaurants that also sell online, or use Lightspeed | $79 a month | Tablet, QR page or app |
Loyalty Cards
Loyalty Cards puts a stamp or points card in your diners’ Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. AI reads your Google listing, website or Instagram and designs the card, its artwork and the rewards in about a minute, then turns it into a poster or counter card with the QR code on it. On iOS 27 the card becomes a full-art poster pass.
- Price: Free covers up to 50 customers. Plus is $25 a month billed yearly or $30 monthly, for one location with unlimited customers. Pro is $60 or $72 for three locations.
- Good: nothing for diners to install, no point of sale to change, and a Free plan with no time limit and no card.
- Watch out: it doesn’t connect to your point of sale, so staff scan the card to add a stamp or points, and delivery orders aren’t credited automatically.
See Loyalty Cards for restaurants.
Toast Loyalty
Toast’s own program, for restaurants on Toast POS. Diners sign up at the register, when signing the check, on Toast online ordering or in the Toast Local app, and earn by phone number, email or card.
- Price: not published. Toast lists it as an add-on with email marketing and gift cards, and it’s also part of the $499 a month Toast IQ Grow bundle.
- Good: earning is automatic at checkout and on Toast’s own online orders.
- Watch out: it needs Toast POS on Toast hardware, Toast’s pages don’t mention Apple Wallet or Google Wallet passes, and points can’t be earned on delivery-app orders.
Read Loyalty Cards vs Toast Loyalty.
Square Loyalty
Square’s program, part of the Square Plus plan. Customers earn at Square checkout, for example by entering a phone number.
- Price: included in Square Plus, which Square lists at $49 a month per location, along with its other point of sale tools.
- Good: automatic earning at checkout, and Square Loyalty free for your first 30 days.
- Watch out: it only works on Square’s own products, and its loyalty page mentions an Apple Wallet pass but not Google Wallet.
Read Loyalty Cards vs Square Loyalty.
Loopy Loyalty
A straightforward wallet stamp card for Apple Wallet and Google Wallet.
- Price: Starter is $25 a month or $250 a year; Growth, which adds the card customizations, is $69 a month.
- Good: no app for diners, unlimited customers, and plans up to 10 locations.
- Watch out: card customizations start on Growth, there’s no AI design or flyer maker, there’s no free plan, and its 15 free days need a card to go live.
Read Loyalty Cards vs Loopy Loyalty.
Stamp Me
A stamp card program where customers join in the Stamp Me app, with optional StampPod and StampTag hardware for stamping.
- Price: Lite is $49 a month and Pro $79, each for a single location.
- Good: unlimited staff, pre-designed posters, and 30 free days that start from your first published card.
- Watch out: diners have to download the Stamp Me app to join.
Read Loyalty Cards vs Stamp Me.
Boomerangme
A loyalty and marketing suite with wallet cards, many card types and point of sale integrations.
- Price: Business is $199 a month, $179 billed quarterly or $164 billed yearly.
- Good: stamp, coupon, cashback, gift and membership cards; Square and Toast integrations; SMS, email, geofenced pushes and an automation builder; 14 free days with no card.
- Watch out: the cheapest plan costs more than six times a single-location Loyalty Cards plan, which is a lot to pay for tools a small restaurant may not use.
Read Loyalty Cards vs Boomerangme.
Kangaroo Rewards
A points platform with point of sale and e-commerce integrations, including Lightspeed Restaurant.
- Price: Core is $79 a month, Plus $199 and Elite $349, which adds a branded app.
- Good: unlimited customers, tiers and referrals from Plus, and points that sync from Lightspeed, Shopify and other systems.
- Watch out: you start by booking a demo, its published terms need 90 days’ notice to cancel, and we found no Apple Wallet or Google Wallet pass or stamp card.
Read Loyalty Cards vs Kangaroo Rewards.
Bigger chains
Restaurant groups with dozens of locations and their own ordering app often use enterprise platforms such as Thanx, Paytronix or Punchh, which build a program around your app and are sold through their sales teams. They’re beyond what most independent restaurants need, so we haven’t compared them here.
How to choose
- Start from your point of sale. If you’re on Toast or Square and automatic earning matters most, try their program first.
- Decide whether diners should install anything. Most won’t download an app for a restaurant they visit a few times a month; a wallet card avoids that.
- Count the tools you’ll really use. SMS journeys, geofencing and coupon cards are worth paying for only if someone will run them.
- Check the exit. Prefer a free plan or monthly billing over contracts that renew automatically.
- Try it on a quiet afternoon. Join as a diner, earn a stamp and redeem a reward before you print anything.
Not ready for a digital program? Our free punch card maker prints restaurant stamp cards ten to a sheet.
Sources: Toast pricing, Toast Loyalty, Square Loyalty, Loopy Loyalty pricing, Stamp Me pricing, Boomerangme pricing, Kangaroo pricing, and our own pricing.
Last updated November 11, 2026











